Our First Applicant!

Here I am almost a year after my previous post with news that yesterday we received our first F-1 applicant! Woohoo! Now my head is buzzing with next steps. Of course I want this to work out, but we’ll still have to vet his application and make sure he’s a good fit. We’ll need to interview him, but still, this is progress and very exciting!

I’ll need to pull together a couple of people who may want to sit in on the interview with me. He’s indicated that he wants to get a diploma from us, so we’ll have to take a look at his transcript and make sure that all checks out.

Oh gosh, there’s so much to do!

Deadline

So today was the deadline for student applicants coming through the four recruiting agencies we agreed to work with. Unfortunately, I have no emails in my inbox alerting me to any new applications for the 2016-2017 school year.

Huh.

I’ll probably get in touch with them to say that we’ll be “extending the deadline”, but I don’t know if that will make much of a difference. I did hear from Educatius that they want to feature our school in next year’s publication, but we were a little late to the game for this year’s. Ok, fair enough.

I’m hanging on to the advice I heard while in Europe that these programs take 12-18 months to get rolling and that I shouldn’t feel bad if I don’t get anyone at first. That seems to be the case. So I’m just going to take the long view.

Of course it’s hard though. I’m disappointed. I’m unsure of what else or what more I could have done. I do feel like getting tuition-paying students is somehow inevitable. The structure of the program we have developed has good bones. It’s just a matter of time. So I’m taking a deep breath and digging a little deeper to find the patience needed for this moment. It’s ok that it hasn’t worked out yet, because the future is a big place.

Back in the States

IMG_0265
My booth in Norway

What a fascinating trip to Europe! I had a handful of conversations with kids and parents, and many conversations with European recruiters. I wish I could come back saying, “We have 5 kids signed up!” But I don’t of course. The other school reps advised me that it often takes 12-18 months to really get into this market and that I shouldn’t worry if I don’t get anyone at first. I’m still hopeful, but it’s tough to say what will happen by the end of May (which is our student deadline).

For many of the school reps there, this kind of trip is their bread and butter. They spend 3-6 months a year on the road talking about their school. Fascinating. There were lots of Canadians, Australians, and New Zealanders (they called themselves Kiwis). There were a handful of other Americans on this trip, and I was certainly the only American Public School.

Curiously enough, most of the other Canadian, Australian, and New Zealand schools represented there were public. In Australia they were called “Government Schools”, but it’s the same idea.

The last night I was there, at the last agency-sponsored dinner, I sat next to a guy from Queensland, Australia and across from the Sales and Marketing head for this agency. FYI, Queensland is a state of Australia. It was a magical dinner, mostly because my head exploded with an idea. The guy from Queensland, Australia represented ALL of the public or government schools in Queensland, and it occurred to me. Why wasn’t I there representing ALL of the public schools from Vermont? We’re all on the same team. I love Vermont on the whole quite dearly. We could do this. It was great to hear from this guy how his system worked, and likewise, it would good to hear from the head of sales why that might be an advantageous system from a marketing perspective.

There are some key differences regarding why it works as it does for Queensland. For example, this guy’s department oversees quality of government schools. It’s as if NEASC were housed with the Agency of Education. They also oversee all of the recruitment for each school. Any international student intending on attending a Queensland school must go through his department anyway. So it’s pretty natural that he would be there for recruiting, as they’d all funnel through him anyway.

IMG_0400
Presenting in Spain

This lady from Sales and Marketing suggested that I look at the model set up by Nova Scotia. Apparently every Canadian public school recruits, and Nova Scotia has it pretty dialed in. They have a good reputation educationally, and they have made a conscious effort to keep international tuition rates to below $20,000 specifically in order to keep their schools attractive and affordable for the “middle class of the world”, so they’re not just getting kids of the super rich.

Upon my return to the US (like the very next day), I went to a discussion about the possibility of a consortium of schools working with this one particular agency regarding a dual diploma program. It was difficult to tell how interested the participating schools were in pursuing this specific option, but it does seem like Vermont is ripe for some kind  of consortium.

After checking in with Jeff Francis (so grateful), it seemed like the best course of action was still to wait a bit. We need to have some success with our program here at Montpelier before I go peddling a consortium.

But please believe that when it happens, it will be independent of any specific corporate obligations. We would issue an RFP. We would have options. We would likely go with CSIET certified agencies.

Overall, I had a great experience in four different European countries: Norway, Germany, Spain, and Iceland.

 

 

 

Europe on Wednesday!

IMG_9849 (1)
Perhaps by the time I get back Spring will have settled in!

A few weeks ago I signed up to go to Europe with Educatius. I’ll be setting up a table at a school fair and hopefully talking with students and parents about Montpelier High School as they mill around checking out schools. In addition I’ll be giving a 10 minute pitch of Montpelier High School to a couple of groups of recruiting agents from around Europe.

This trip will take me to Norway, Germany, and Spain. I’ll also be spending a couple of extra days in Iceland as an extended layover. And I leave this Wednesday!

I’m starting to get nervous.

I finished my google slides presentation today for the recruiting agents. And I practiced my pitch on my parents. I’m borrowing my sister’s luggage because it’s much larger than anything I own. Hopefully the banner for the table arrives before I have to leave on Wednesday! It’s time to start making a list of all the things that must be done before I can leave.

Mail my taxes. Write lesson plans. Find coaching subs. Pack! Pack! Pack!

I’m so grateful. What an adventure!

It’s funny, I really love Vermont a lot. At one point I thought I would never leave Vermont again, but instead I’m leaving Vermont just to go to another continent to talk about how awesome Vermont is! Ha!

This trip will be very different than the trip to Thailand for lots of reasons, but one of them being that I’m not in charge of the trip exactly. I mean, I have to get myself places, but then hopefully someone else will run the show!

 

 

Three New Resources

I’m out in Schenectady, NY this weekend with the Knowles Science Teaching Foundation putting together a new branch of the organization that plans to offer professional development experiences for teachers. This PD will help science and math teachers incorporate engineering design into their existing curricula. Awesome.

As usual, hanging out with Knowles Fellows is refreshing and inspiring. There are these tangential things that you learn, which are super valuable. Here are three of them.

Screen Shot 2016-03-06 at 10.23.33 PM1.  Canva. Our group was like “we need a flier!” and then one of our members made the coolest looking flier in a pretty short amount of time. And she used Canva to do it!

2. Phet. I’ve known about this physics-teaching tool for a long time, but I kept forgetting the site. The reason I kept forgetting what they were called is because I got it in my head that they were called physlets (physics-related java applets). And that’s a thing, but honestly, they’re not as cool as Phets. I’m going to need to remember that link by the time I’m back to teaching physics. In fact, maybe I can use one to teach the Carnot Cycle to my engineering students!

3. Ok, this isn’t an app, and again I think I knew about this before, but we watched this TED talk on the Golden Circle as a group, just to help us think through the language around our mission statement and vision statement.

So this post has been a little bit of an aside from my usual postings, but it was a good weekend with good friends!

 

The Woes of Being an Overachiever

IMG_9742
It just so happens that my post-conference bed and breakfast is minutes away from Harvard Yard. This was on my walk to dinner.

Today was one of those days where everything changes. My perspective has shifted since yesterday, and I think that’s a good thing.

Today was the Educatius Public F-1 School Summit. Ok, I just made up that name, but that’s basically who was there: all public schools with international F-1 programs, all in the same room talking about our challenges and successes in dealing with international students. Oh my gosh, in some small way it was like finding my people. So far, I have found painfully few public schools running F-1 programs. I mean, it’s basically been Newcomb in NY and Stearns in Maine. That’s it. Then here was a whole roomful of principals, vice principals, guidance counselors, and international coordinators from schools all over New England who are involved in the very same work I am doing! Ok, mainly they were from Massachusetts, but still, how delightful. I now have a new handful of places I could go visit or at least communicate with about what’s working.

Afterward, I had a very frank conversation with Steve from Educatius during which my paradigm shifted.

I learned that Montpelier is priced such that it’s in the “select” group, which means it’s expensive, and it’s a roll of the dice as to how many students will want to go there. In Educatius’ “basic” program students don’t get a choice, they just get placed at a school. Some schools look more appealing than others in the “select” group. But no guarantees.

I also found out that by directly recruiting, and posting that package cost on the website, we have basically told our recruiting agencies that we are undercutting them. I knew this (sort of) from a conversation with a different recruiting agency, but no one else asked about direct recruiting, so I just assumed that it didn’t matter to them. Turns out it does matter. You know, between the difficulty with direct background checks for host families and now this, I am really just inclined to not directly recruit at all.

In fact, the phrase that’s settling in for me is that at Montpelier High School education is our business, not prepping and supporting host families. Perhaps in my eagerness to do a thorough and complete job I have overestimated the amount of work I need to do. Perhaps I really just need to hire this part out and then not worry about it. That is where the shift is occurring: that I can let go of all the work that would come from directly recruiting. Now if a student from Thailand does want to come to Montpelier, I can direct them to this agency. Easy. Of course I’ll be involved with finding host families and supporting these students, and probably coming up with a Montpelier-specific orientation, but I probably don’t need to do the host family prep. And that’s probably good, because I am SO not qualified to do that. I have no idea as to what would need to be included.

Meanwhile Educatius has a European tour in April. I think I should go.

 

Introducing Volatility (Or Stability) into the System

So it’s late, but I’m feeling the need to capture this idea because I think it’s important, but it would be easy to overlook at this stage.

I had an interesting conversation today with the local coordinator for CIEE, which runs a J-1 visa program and often sends students to Montpelier HS. I was telling her about the F-1 policy that I’m drafting presently, based on Newcomb’s F-1 Policy. Their policy requires a ratio of students from Asia, Europe, and South America. It also sets a limit of four students who speak the same first language.

My steering committee decided that was too narrow or limiting and we just said that diversity of nationalities and languages would be considered in the selection process.

But this lady reminded me of something I haven’t thought about in a long time. Perhaps we want a statement like, “No more than 10% of our student body will be F-1 visa students.” Or maybe it should be something like, “The number of F-1 seats available will be the difference between 100 students and the number of residents students.” Thus basically maintaining the size of each class.

This is a way to achieve population stability. (Of course, assuming that we can fill these seats, and that that number doesn’t exceed, say 10% of our total population.)

The other thing is that, if we aren’t careful, we could end up introducing a noticeable amount of volatility in the school budget tax rate. That money either goes towards reducing homeowners’ tax rate or it goes into the general fund. If we have an unmet reserve fund policy, then perhaps this will help us catch up on that, but I think we need to be intentional about what we’re going to do with that money.

For that purpose I actually really like the idea of setting the class size. We could set it such that there were enough students so that no one had to be part time! Wouldn’t that be great! I might need to crunch some numbers to see roughly how many students it would take for the whole faculty to be full time. What’s that threshold? Interesting stuff.

Public School Background Checks for Host Families

 

Screen Shot 2016-02-12 at 4.11.36 PM

Following a recent, nice article in the latest issue of the Bridge, I’m starting to kick into gear with host families. I have a handful of leads for families (*whew*) but I could always use more. But of course, at this point, no one has actually applied to be a host family. I’ll press on that a little harder when the time gets comes, but there’s this one piece of this process that’s unexpectedly difficult: background checks.

You would think background checks for host families would totally be in the wheelhouse of a school district. We do them all the time for teachers, but it turns out that it’s not a simple thing to extend that to host families.

Here’s a short primer on background checks as I understand them.

The Vermont Criminal Information Center (VCIC) discusses mainly two types of background checks: State (name & DOB) level, and fingerprint-supported FBI level. The latter is an inter-state criminal record check. Only certain kinds of organizations qualify to do that kind of background check: Educational entities and those covered by the National Child Protection Act (NCPA). The relevant part for us is that covered under the NCPA are organizations whose primary mission is to supervise children.

The school issues FBI background checks for all of its employees, including non-educator staff. But we weren’t planning on treating the host families like employees, nor as volunteers, but rather as independent contractors. The school doesn’t runs background checks on its independent contractors. And we can’t just run a background check on anyone we want to all willy-nilly.

When the superintendent’s office gives a new potential employee a form to take to the sheriff’s office for fingerprinting, Education and NCPA are different boxes that they might check. But schools are only authorized to check the “Education” box. In order to run a background check under the NCPA, you have to request permission from the VCIC to see if you qualify. And, by the way, you have to submit this request in writing on the letterhead of the agency requesting permission to run the checks.

Here are some options in order of feasibility, first being most likely:

  1. We only accept students through agencies. They’ll do their own background check process.
  2. We hire host families as “employees” not independent contractors and then they do qualify under our “Educational” check.
  3. We classify host families as “volunteers” and then we tell them that we would reimburse them for up to $700/month for expenses incurred by hosting.
  4. We form a distinct entity (legally separate) that can issue FBI-level background checks. This seems like a crazy amount of work. 
  5. We get our current “user agreement” to include NCPA type checks. I’ve sort of been told that we won’t qualify for this type of check “as supervision of children” is not our “primary function”, even though it sort of is. 
  6. We don’t tell VCIC and then just check the “NCPA” box instead of the “Educational” box. Ok, this is really quite feasible, but it’s not honest and I want this to be entirely on the up & up. 
  7. A lawyer tells us that we don’t need FBI supported background checks, and we have other internet based options, or we just need to do the State-level background check. I know at least one private school in Vermont that doesn’t run FBI background checks on their host families, they do an internet based check, probably like NCSI (which is what USA Ultimate uses), but my contact there thought that the rules might be different for public schools. That might be true, but why would the rules for private schools be different about this? Safety law for children should transcend the type of school issuing the background check.

This is an issue that we have to get right. It’s high stakes legally and in terms of the very safety of the kids paying to be here. I don’t think this problem is prohibitive, but it’s unclear to me which option will win out. (Which maybe also means, that I sort of love it! “What?! A real challenge? Sweet!”)

In the Media

It seems as though this idea of foreign students paying a boat load of money to go to school in America is catching a lot of media attention lately. I was supposed to do an interview with NPR this week, but they had to cancel. Funny, it wasn’t with the author of this NPR story. I wonder if he’ll want to do the story at all now that it’s sort of already been done.

Additionally, the Boston Globe just got in touch with me about doing a story, which we’ll probably do in the coming months, and then I’m supposed to do an interview for the next issue of the Bridge.

The Bridge article would be probably the most valuable to me because I’m about to need a database of host families.

It’s entirely possible that we’ll have 10 students here for 10 days over April from the Patumwan Demonstration School in Thailand, coming to check out the school. We’ll see! I want to at least be somewhat prepared when they say they’re ready to go!

IMG_9414
The Montpelier Crew with the Team from the Patumwan Demonstration School.

We’re Back!

What an amazing trip! The people were so kind. The food was extraordinary everywhere we went. We all had a good time. We made our flights to and from Ubon Ratchathani. All of the logistics worked out (except for the very last plane ride, which we miseed), including meeting with all of the schools I had planned to visit. We met with seven schools, and they were all receptive to pursuing a partnership with us. Let me chronicle our time a little bit here:

  1. Bangkok Christian College: We met with an administrator who said that she would follow up with her superiors to ask them about possible partnership. Kathleen, our Bangkok connection, was present for our virgin presentation, and she thought it went well. She was impressed with how professional it was. Certainly we got better at our presentation by the last school, but it was nice to get some positive feedback right off the bat.
  2. Assumption St. Gabriel School: Our second presentation could not have been more different. We were met by a very kIMG_0709 (1)ind fellow who showed us to a sitting room that was richly decorated, and then from there to a conference room with a giant table. They gave us pre-packaged sandwiches and yogurt with berries and lattes with different drizzled patterns in on the surface. There were at least five different guys there all waiting for the headmaster to join us. When he arrived it felt like meeting the president or the pope, IMG_0712though I have no real context for what that must actually be like. Our presentation went well, and they were very interested and invited us back for a second meeting to work out logistics. That communicated the legitimacy of their interest. Additionally they were interested in sending a Thai teacher along with a group of students for the year, as it would help the teacher’s English and Thai families would feel more comfortable sending their student overseas with someone who spoke Thai. Super interesting.
  3. Assumption Samutprakarn School: Immediately after our time with the St. Gabriel School we went to another Assumption school right in Bangkok. They sent a van to pick us up. This school had a lovely lush courtyard with statues and they served us lunch prior to our meeting. This was the only meeting where the Thai reps were all women. By the end of that meeting they had suggested that we sign an MOU with them by the end of the week. Of course we could not do that, but we said we would talk about it. They were also interested in sending teachers as well as hosting American teachers. At our follow-up meeting with them they suggested that they send their kids to America for a month in October to check out the school and see if they thought it was a good fit and wanted to continue. A month seems like an awfully long time to check out a school, but I appreciate the idea.
  4. Niva International School: This was Heather’s old schFullSizeRender (15)ool. We met with the headmaster Mr. Anthony in the only meeting where there was no table to sit around. Instead we were just in his office. Even though that space was air conditioned I remember that day as being extraordinarily hot. This meeting really hammered home that our program cost 1,000,000 baht, a rather unfortunate number. He said it would be too expensive for most students, but then said that they would indeed like to partner with us, and that some students would be able to afford it.
  5. Benchama School: This school in Ubon Ratchathani was the first real public school that we went to. Suvannee helped with language questions, but there was at least one guy (among 5 or 6) on staff in the meeting who seemed to be able to understand us well. By the end of the meeting they decided to film a little advertisement with us to show to students so that hopefully they would want to come to our school. For this filmed ad we went through an abbreviated version of our presentation sort of on the fly, but I think it went well.
  6. Assumption Ubon Ratchathani: ThiFullSizeRender (8)s was Austin’s school (a former student of mine). And it really was nice to have that connection. This was a part of the same Assumption network as the Assumption schools we visited in Bangkok. Again, they expressed concern about the price, but did say that there would be some students who could afford it and might be interested.
  7. Patunwam Demonstration School: Back in Bangkok, this was our last and best presentation. This school also had some other things working in our favor. Their style of education was more western: project-based, AP classes, more than just multiple choice-style tests. This might have been one of the most affluent schools we went to, so it was not surprising that they balked the least at our price. They also were keen on sending us students ahead of time. They were thinking for 10 days in April, which is oh-my-gosh-soon.  I think we’re good to move forward with that, but I need to get moving on that like yesterday. 😛

There is, of course, so much more to tell about the people, the places, the food, but this post is already plenty long. Perhaps I’ll unpack some of that in another post.